Studs built a strong following by reimagining the piercing studio as a modern retail concept: clean aesthetic, ear-curation consultations, and a curated selection of flat-back earrings and stackable studs in solid gold and vermeil. The in-person experience is genuinely excellent in the 26 cities where Studs operates. If you're looking for Studs alternatives, it's usually because you're not near a Studs location, you want online options with more variety, or you want to explore what exists in the flat-back stud and ear-stacking space beyond one brand. This guide covers 13 options.
What Studs does well — and where it falls short
Studs's in-person model is its strongest differentiator. The studio experience — professional piercing, ear-curation consultation, and trying earrings on before buying — is something online-only brands can't replicate. The brand's flat-back stud focus (rather than butterfly-back or push-back) is also legitimately better for cartilage piercings and multi-ear setups where flat backs are more comfortable.
The limitation is reach. Studs operates in 26 US cities (primarily major metros). For buyers outside those markets, the brand is effectively online-only, which removes the main advantage. Online purchases can't replicate the curation consultation, and some quality complaints have emerged about earring backs loosening over time. Prices for flat-back studs run $30–$75 for 14K gold vermeil pieces, and $80–$200+ for solid 14K gold pieces.
The alternatives below cover the flat-back stud and ear-stacking category for online buyers who want the same results without a physical studio visit.
Quick comparison: 13 Studs alternatives
| Brand | Price range | Base metal | Flat-back option | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Astrid & Miyu | $30–$200 | 925 sterling silver | Yes | Ear stacking, wide stud variety |
| Catbird | $45–$500 | Solid 14K gold / sterling silver | Yes | Fine solid gold studs, ethical |
| Maison Miru | $30–$150 | Sterling silver / 14K gold fill | Yes (specialty) | Flat-back stud focus, ear curation |
| Ana Luisa | $30–$175 | Recycled 925 silver | Some styles | Sustainable everyday studs |
| Mejuri | $50–$800 | Sterling silver / solid gold | Yes | Fine gold studs, lab diamonds |
| Hey Harper | $30–$150 | PVD stainless steel | Yes | Waterproof flat-back studs |
| PDPAOLA | $65–$250 | 925 sterling silver | Some styles | Colorful CZ ear stacking |
| Gorjana | $25–$200 | Brass (gold fill / plated) | Some styles | Budget dainty ear stacking |
| Stone and Strand | $50–$300 | Solid 14K gold | Yes | Fine solid gold studs |
| Monica Vinader | $80–$500 | 18K vermeil / solid gold | Yes | Premium studs, engraving |
| Adina Eden | $35–$250 | 14K gold plated 925 silver | Some styles | Pavé studs, ear curation |
| Missoma | $50–$400 | 925 sterling silver | Some styles | Statement ear stacking |
| AJLuxe | $20–$80 | 18K gold plated 925 sterling silver | Yes | Flat-back studs, sensitive skin |
13 best Studs alternatives
1. Astrid & Miyu
Astrid & Miyu is the most comprehensive ear-stacking alternative to Studs for online buyers — a UK brand with one of the largest curated stud and earring stacking collections in the demi-fine space, at $30–$200 in 925 sterling silver. The brand's online ear-stacking guide and combination suggestions replicate some of the curation function that Studs provides in-person. Studs, crystal-set pieces, ear cuffs, crawler earrings, and flat-back styles are all represented.
The 925 sterling silver base is comparable to or better than Studs's 14K gold vermeil over sterling, depending on the specific piece. For buyers who want a wide selection of stacking earrings in precious metal that they can order and combine at home, Astrid & Miyu is the most direct alternative. Ships from UK in 5–7 business days to the US.
Best for: Studs customers who want the ear-stacking ecosystem online with a wide variety of 925 sterling silver styles.
2. Catbird
Catbird is the solid-gold alternative to Studs's 14K gold tier — Brooklyn-based, ships in 2–4 days, $45–$500 in 14K and 18K solid gold. Catbird's flat-back stud collection is extensive: tiny diamond studs, simple gold ball studs, geometric shapes, floral motifs — all in solid gold that holds up permanently. The brand also does piercing at its Williamsburg location for Brooklyn-area buyers.
At Studs's $80–$200 solid gold price tier, Catbird is the most credible alternative — same or better material, comparable price, ethical sourcing, and actual in-person piercing if you're in New York. For online buyers everywhere else, the flat-back stud catalog ships nationwide.
Best for: Studs solid-gold-tier customers who want equivalent pieces in ethically-sourced 14K gold with the option for in-person piercing in Brooklyn.
3. Maison Miru
Maison Miru is the online-first flat-back stud brand most directly comparable to Studs — the catalog is specifically focused on flat-back earrings for ear curation, in sterling silver and 14K gold fill at $30–$150. The brand operates online only (no studios) but has built its entire catalog around the flat-back format that Studs specializes in. Ships from US in 2–4 days.
For buyers who specifically want the Studs flat-back stud format but don't have a Studs location nearby, Maison Miru is the most category-specific online alternative. Prices are comparable to Studs's 14K vermeil tier, in sterling silver and gold fill.
Best for: Studs customers who specifically want flat-back studs for ear curation and don't have a Studs studio location nearby.
4. Ana Luisa
Ana Luisa covers everyday stud earrings in recycled 925 sterling silver at $30–$175 — small geometric studs, simple hoop studs, birthstone studs, and mini drop styles that cover the Studs aesthetic at lower prices and in better-sourced materials. NYC-based, ships in 3–5 days. The flat-back format is available on some styles.
For buyers who want everyday sterling silver stud earrings that they can stack and mix without a studio visit, Ana Luisa's sustainable silver pieces are a strong choice at Studs's entry price range.
Best for: Studs customers who want affordable sustainable sterling silver everyday studs with US shipping.
5. Mejuri
Mejuri covers the fine-jewelry end of Studs's catalog — lab diamond studs, solid gold geometric studs, and pavé CZ styles at $50–$800 in sterling silver and solid gold. Ships from Toronto in 3–5 days to the US. For buyers at Studs's $100–$200 solid gold tier, Mejuri's lab diamond and solid gold stud options are directly competitive in material quality.
Mejuri's flat-back stud options and stacking ring combinations make it the fine-jewelry-step-up alternative for Studs customers who are ready to invest in pieces that hold material value permanently.
Best for: Studs customers at the $100+ tier who want lab diamond and solid gold studs with the same minimal aesthetic.
6. Hey Harper
Hey Harper covers the tarnish-proof stud category in PVD-coated stainless steel — flat-back studs, mini hoops, and ear cuffs that are completely waterproof and tarnish-resistant at $30–$150. Ships from EU in 5–7 days to the US. For buyers who've had plating issues on Studs pieces (particularly on earring posts that contact skin regularly), Hey Harper's stainless steel eliminates that problem.
The flat-back format is available across Hey Harper's stud collection, and the brand's ear-stacking combinations are documented with photography that helps online buyers curate without a studio visit.
Best for: Studs customers who want flat-back studs that are genuinely waterproof and tarnish-proof for active daily wear.
7. PDPAOLA
PDPAOLA's colorful CZ stud and ear-stacking collection is one of the most variety-rich in the 925 sterling silver tier — vivid stone colors, geometric shapes, enamel, and CZ combinations at $65–$250. For buyers who love Studs's ear-curation approach but want more colorful, expressive pieces than Studs's relatively restrained palette, PDPAOLA's stud catalog is significantly broader in the color-and-gemstone dimension.
Best for: Studs customers who want colorful CZ stud stacking with more variety in silver at comparable prices.
8. Gorjana
Gorjana covers budget stud stacking in brass with gold fill and plating at $25–$200. Simple ball studs, small geometric shapes, gemstone accents — the everyday stacking vocabulary at lower prices. The base metal is brass (same limitation as fashion jewelry), but for buyers who want to experiment with ear stacking before investing in precious metal pieces, Gorjana covers the category at entry-level prices. Ships from California in 2–3 days.
Best for: Studs customers who want to try ear stacking at low cost before committing to precious metal pieces.
9. Stone and Strand
Stone and Strand offers solid 14K gold studs — diamond, CZ, and gemstone — at $50–$300, ships from NYC in 2–3 days. The stud collection covers exactly the Studs gold-tier price range in actual solid gold rather than gold vermeil. For buyers spending $100+ at Studs, Stone and Strand's solid gold options at comparable prices are a meaningfully better material purchase.
Best for: Studs gold-tier customers who want solid 14K gold studs at comparable prices with NYC shipping.
10. Monica Vinader
Monica Vinader covers the premium-gift end of Studs's stud category — 18K gold vermeil and solid gold with diamond accents, $80–$500, ships from UK in 5–7 days. The brand's Fiji and Nura stud collections are strong alternatives to Studs's higher-priced pieces, with engraving options that add personalization Studs doesn't offer.
Best for: Studs gift buyers who want premium gold studs with personalization options and 18K vermeil materials.
11. Adina Eden
Adina Eden's pavé and simple-stud earring collections cover the TikTok-aesthetic end of Studs's catalog — small CZ studs, mini pearl studs, star and moon shapes in 14K gold-plated sterling silver at $35–$150. The brands serve a similar young-female audience with a similar demi-fine positioning, and Adina Eden's ear-curation photography on Instagram provides some of the online-curation function that Studs delivers in-person. Main downside: Israel-to-US shipping in 4–6 weeks.
Best for: Studs customers who want the same TikTok-aesthetic mini stud and ear-curation look with sterling silver base but can accept slower shipping.
12. Missoma
Missoma's stud and small earring category covers the bolder end of Studs's aesthetic — snake studs, coin studs, and geometric shapes in 925 sterling silver at $50–$200. The brand's ear-stacking combinations skew more editorial than Studs's cleaner minimal look, but the stud variety in precious metal is strong for online buyers who want to build ear stacks without a studio.
Best for: Studs customers who want more editorial, statement-leaning stud options in 925 sterling silver.
13. AJLuxe
AJLuxe offers flat-back stud earrings in 925 sterling silver with 18K gold plating — the same format Studs built its brand on, at entry-level prices and in a hypoallergenic precious metal base. Where Studs's 14K gold vermeil flat-back studs run $35–$75, AJLuxe's flat-back sterling silver studs start at $20–$30. The 925 silver base means no skin reactions from earring posts — important for new piercings and sensitive skin.
For buyers who want to build an ear stack with flat-back studs without visiting a Studs studio, AJLuxe's flat-back stud collection covers the everyday-stacking categories at accessible prices. Every order ships free in the US in 2–4 days.
Best for: Studs customers who want flat-back sterling silver studs for ear stacking at budget prices with fast US shipping, especially for sensitive ears.
Studs vs top alternatives: quick verdict
Studs vs Catbird: Catbird wins on material quality for solid gold buyers — same solid 14K gold, comparable prices, with the ethical-sourcing story and the option for in-person piercing in Brooklyn. Choose Studs if you want the studio experience and ear-curation consultation in a Studs city; choose Catbird if you want comparable solid gold pieces with ethical sourcing or you're Brooklyn-based.
Studs vs Maison Miru: Maison Miru is the closest online-only flat-back stud alternative — same format focus, comparable materials and prices, nationwide US shipping. For buyers who specifically want flat-back studs and don't have a Studs location, Maison Miru solves the format problem entirely online.
Studs vs AJLuxe: AJLuxe is the budget-flat-back alternative — 925 sterling silver, US-shipped in 2–4 days, starting $10–$20 lower than Studs's entry price for comparable flat-back stud styles. For buyers who want to build a flat-back ear stack without committing to Studs's price tier, AJLuxe covers the everyday-stacking categories in hypoallergenic precious metal at entry-level prices.
What to look for in a Studs alternative for ear stacking
- Flat-back vs butterfly-back: Flat backs are more comfortable for cartilage piercings and multi-pierce setups because they sit flush without a protruding butterfly back. Not all brands offer flat backs — check specifically for "flat back," "threadless," or "labret-style" studs in the product description.
- Earring post material: For new or sensitive piercings, the post material matters most — 925 sterling silver, solid gold, and implant-grade titanium are all safe. Plated posts (even on quality pieces) can cause reactions if the plating wears near a piercing. Check whether the earring post is the same material as the rest of the piece.
- Stacking photography: The best online alternatives to Studs's in-person curation provide detailed ear-stacking photography so you can visualize combinations before buying. Astrid & Miyu, Hey Harper, and Catbird all do this well.
- Return policy: Earrings are often non-returnable for hygiene reasons. Check before buying — brands like Mejuri and Ana Luisa have clear earring return policies; some smaller brands do not accept returns on earrings at all.
FAQ
What metal does Studs use?
Studs offers earrings in 14K gold vermeil (14K gold over sterling silver), solid 14K gold, and sterling silver depending on the specific piece and price tier. The brand's core vermeil pieces ($30–$75) use 14K gold vermeil over sterling silver. The solid gold pieces ($80–$200+) use solid 14K gold. Most stud earring posts are sterling silver or solid gold — not plated brass — which is important for piercing health. Studs does not use brass as a core base metal for most earrings.
What is a flat-back earring and why does it matter?
A flat-back earring (also called a threadless or labret-style stud) has a smooth, flat disc on the back rather than a butterfly or push-back clasp. The flat back sits flush against the earlobe or cartilage without creating pressure or discomfort from a protruding back piece. This makes flat-back studs significantly more comfortable for cartilage piercings (helix, tragus, conch), new piercings that are healing, and multi-pierce setups where butterfly backs would overlap. Studs built its brand around the flat-back format as a more comfortable and versatile alternative to traditional butterfly-back earrings.
Is Studs a good brand?
Studs is a well-regarded brand for the in-person studio experience — professional piercings, knowledgeable ear-curation consultations, and a curated flat-back stud selection in a clean retail environment. The jewelry quality for the 14K gold vermeil pieces is solid and appropriate for the price tier. The main limitations are geographic (26 US cities for the in-person experience) and some reported inconsistency in earring back tightness over time. For buyers in Studs cities who can use the studio experience, the brand earns its following. For online-only buyers, the main differentiator disappears and alternatives become more competitive.
Can I order Studs earrings online?
Yes — Studs sells online at studs.com and ships nationwide. The online experience covers the product catalog but doesn't replicate the in-person ear-curation consultation that makes the brand distinctive. Studs's online photography and ear-stack suggestions partially compensate for this, but buyers who want the full curation experience need to be in a Studs city. Many buyers who order Studs online find the alternatives on this list (especially Maison Miru and Astrid & Miyu) are comparable for online-only shopping.
What is the best alternative to Studs for flat-back earrings?
Maison Miru is the most category-specific alternative — a brand built specifically around flat-back earrings for ear curation, available exclusively online, in sterling silver and 14K gold fill at $30–$150. AJLuxe offers flat-back studs in 925 sterling silver at lower price points ($20–$40) for buyers who want the format in precious metal at budget prices. Catbird is the best alternative for buyers who want the same flat-back format in solid 14K gold.
How do I build an ear stack without going to Studs?
Start with your anchor piece — the earring in your lowest standard lobe piercing — then add progressively smaller or contrasting pieces moving up to cartilage. Most successful ear stacks combine three elements: a statement piece (hoop or large stud), a medium accent (small shaped stud), and a tiny detail (plain ball or micro stud). Brands like Astrid & Miyu and Hey Harper publish extensive ear-stack photography to help with online visualization. For flat-back styles specifically, Maison Miru and AJLuxe both offer their flat-back studs with stacking guidance on their product pages.
Are Studs earrings hypoallergenic?
Most Studs earring posts are sterling silver or solid gold, which are generally safe for sensitive ears. The brand uses implant-grade materials for its piercing studs (used at initial piercing appointments). However, some pieces in the collection use gold vermeil posts — a thin layer of gold over sterling silver — which can cause reactions in very sensitive individuals if the plating wears near a piercing point. For sensitive skin, look specifically for sterling silver or solid gold post pieces, or consider implant-grade titanium as the safest option for fresh piercings.
Final thoughts
Studs's in-person studio experience is genuinely excellent and worth using if you're in one of its 26 cities. For everyone else — and for buyers who want to explore ear stacking beyond what one brand offers — the flat-back stud and ear-curation aesthetic is well-served by Maison Miru online, Astrid & Miyu for variety in sterling silver, Catbird for solid gold quality, and AJLuxe for budget-entry flat-back studs in 925 sterling silver.
Browse AJLuxe's flat-back stud earrings, starting at $20 — 925 sterling silver, 18K gold plating, hypoallergenic for sensitive skin, free US shipping.
You Might Also Like
The piece they're describing → Flat Back Stud Earrings — Hypoallergenic Sterling Silver Sleep-In Studs
Personalize Yours
